diff --git a/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-settings-backup.sh b/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-settings-backup.sh
index 2dde3db..c33d4bc 100644
--- a/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-settings-backup.sh
+++ b/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-settings-backup.sh
@@ -70,7 +70,7 @@ else
     echo "=== Checking for StackPacks backup \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\" in bucket \"${BACKUP_CONFIGURATION_LOCAL_BUCKET}\"..."
     setup_aws_credentials
 
-    if download_from_s3 "${BACKUP_CONFIGURATION_LOCAL_BUCKET}" "${BACKUP_CONFIGURATION_S3_PREFIX}${BACKUP_CONFIGURATION_STACKPACKS_DIR}" "${TMP_DIR}" "${STACKPACKS_FILE}"; then
+    if download_from_s3 "${BACKUP_CONFIGURATION_LOCAL_BUCKET}" "${BACKUP_CONFIGURATION_STACKPACKS_DIR}" "${TMP_DIR}" "${STACKPACKS_FILE}"; then
       STACKPACKS_RESTORE_FILE="${TMP_DIR}/${STACKPACKS_FILE}"
     elif [ "${BACKUP_CONFIGURATION_UPLOAD_REMOTE}" == "true" ]; then
       echo "=== StackPacks backup not found in kubernetes settings storage, trying main backups storage..."
@@ -80,8 +80,8 @@ else
     fi
 
     if [ -z "${STACKPACKS_RESTORE_FILE}" ] || [ ! -f "${STACKPACKS_RESTORE_FILE}" ]; then
-      echo "=== WARNING: StackPacks backup \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\" not found, skipping StackPacks restore"
-      exit 0
+      echo "=== ERROR: StackPacks backup \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\" not found"
+      exit 1
     fi
 
     echo "=== Restoring StackPacks from \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\"..."
diff --git a/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-stackgraph-backup.sh b/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-stackgraph-backup.sh
index 3da0526..13b1894 100644
--- a/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-stackgraph-backup.sh
+++ b/internal/scripts/scripts/restore-stackgraph-backup.sh
@@ -25,15 +25,16 @@ else
     echo "=== Checking for StackPacks backup \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\" in bucket \"${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_BUCKET_NAME}\"..."
 
     # Check if stackpacks backup exists in S3
-    if sts-toolbox aws s3 ls --endpoint "http://${MINIO_ENDPOINT}" --region minio --bucket "${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_BUCKET_NAME}" --prefix "${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_S3_PREFIX}${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_STACKPACKS_DIR}${STACKPACKS_FILE}" 2>/dev/null | grep -q "${STACKPACKS_FILE}"; then
-        echo "=== Downloading StackPacks backup..."
-        sts-toolbox aws s3 cp --endpoint "http://${MINIO_ENDPOINT}" --region minio "s3://${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_BUCKET_NAME}/${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_S3_PREFIX}${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_STACKPACKS_DIR}${STACKPACKS_FILE}" "${TMP_DIR}/${STACKPACKS_FILE}"
-
-        echo "=== Restoring StackPacks from \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\"..."
-        /opt/docker/bin/stack-packs-backup -Dlogback.configurationFile=/opt/docker/etc_log/logback.xml -restore "${TMP_DIR}/${STACKPACKS_FILE}"
-        echo "=== StackPacks restore complete"
-    else
-        echo "=== WARNING: StackPacks backup \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\" not found in S3, skipping StackPacks restore"
+    if ! sts-toolbox aws s3 ls --endpoint "http://${MINIO_ENDPOINT}" --region minio --bucket "${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_BUCKET_NAME}" --prefix "${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_S3_PREFIX}${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_STACKPACKS_DIR}${STACKPACKS_FILE}" 2>/dev/null | grep -q "${STACKPACKS_FILE}"; then
+        echo "=== ERROR: StackPacks backup \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\" not found in S3"
+        exit 1
     fi
+
+    echo "=== Downloading StackPacks backup..."
+    sts-toolbox aws s3 cp --endpoint "http://${MINIO_ENDPOINT}" --region minio "s3://${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_BUCKET_NAME}/${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_S3_PREFIX}${BACKUP_STACKGRAPH_STACKPACKS_DIR}${STACKPACKS_FILE}" "${TMP_DIR}/${STACKPACKS_FILE}"
+
+    echo "=== Restoring StackPacks from \"${STACKPACKS_FILE}\"..."
+    /opt/docker/bin/stack-packs-backup -Dlogback.configurationFile=/opt/docker/etc_log/logback.xml -restore "${TMP_DIR}/${STACKPACKS_FILE}"
+    echo "=== StackPacks restore complete"
 fi
 echo "==="